Main characters:
N, Poppy, Saffra (Poppy's daughter), Tony Balaclava (head of the Dorothy Fish
Day Centre.)
Genre: Fiction, based around
mental health and the mental health care system.
I knew this story well before even looking at the book.
Channel 4 did a feature length rendition of it, staring Anna Maxwell Martin as
N, and Naomie Harris (best known as Tia Dalma/Calypso from the 'Pirates of the
Caribbean' films) as Poppy. It was this version of the story that made me pick
the book up straight away from the library. For those of you who haven't seen
it, you MUST watch it. It's powerful, heartwrenching and so very very well
done. Naomie and Anna play their respective parts perfectly, and it is shot
exactly how it needs to be. It's currently on Youtube, but it is an hour and a
half long, so settle down for a long stint if you plan on watching it.
Blurb: Welcome to the Dorothy Fish, a day hospital
in North London. N has been a patient here for thirteen years. Day after day
she sits smoking in the common room, swapping medication and comparing MAD
money rates. Like all the patients at the Dorothy Fish, N's chief ambition is
never to be discharged. Each year when her annual assessment comes round, she
is relieved to learn that she hasn't got any better.
Then in walks Poppy
Shakespeare in her six-inch skirt and twelve-inch heels. She is certain she
isn't mentally ill and is desperate to return to her life outside. Though
baffled by Poppy's attitude, N agrees to help. Together they plot to gain
Poppy's freedom. But in a world where everything's upside-down, are they crazy
enough to upset the system?
Oh how I wanted to like this book. I really really did. But
this is the first book in a very long time where I haven't been able to finish,
no matter how hard I tried. I got to page 40, which equates to approximately
the first 8 minutes of the TV show. I was so upset when I finally closed it
because I wanted to like it so badly!
It's not that it's a bad book, it's simply the manner in
which the narrative is written, from the perspective of N, that meant I just
couldn't get into it. It's because I'm used to different writing styles to
this: the narrative is really written in the style of a mental patient. Clare
knows a lot about this, as she herself was a patient in a mental health day
hospital for 10 years and so was using this to inform her writing. That and
this being her first novel means that she perhaps had not quite perfected her
writing style.
Poppy Shakespeare is a beautifully tragic tale (I can
comment on the story through watching and reading what I could), in where, to
prove she isn't mad, she must pretend to be mad to gain access to the funds she
needs for a lawyer. So N helps her to complete the forms in the style of a
mentalist, and Poppy acts her heart out to show the staff she's mad enough to
get the funds. However, when it comes to her daughter's father believing that
it's more than an act, N starts to wonder just how sane Poppy really is, and so
does she.
There have been many references to 'Catch-22' and 'One Flew
Over the Cuckoo's Nest', and there are clear similarities between the themes. I
can't comment on how they're presented in the book because sadly, I didn't get
that far. However, from what I have seen of the feature length take on it,
Clare has written some believable, deep characters which make you feel their
pain. It also takes very strongly from the book and that's what I like about it
in particular. I could hear words I'd read hours before coming at me.
Would I read it again?: I would like to give it another
shot, but I wouldn't want to force myself to read past what was enjoyable
simply for the sake of reaching the end of the book. Again: not because it's a
bad book, but because the narrative being written in this style meant that it
just wasn't my cup of tea.
All in all: 3/5 - for true to life, emotional characters and
a story that will damn near break your heart when it gets to the end (not for
watching at 4am like I did!), The narrative is believable, well written as if
spoken and realistic but just not for me.
Name & TGPF username: Lauren - SapphireDreams